4.1 based on 8 reviews

13 Comments

  1. Anonymous says:

    This judge runs a great hearing with no nonsense, though he cherry picks to the extreme in his decisions. He’s not the worst judge you can get in St Pete, but you could definitely do better.

  2. sean fried says:

    I had Bt amos he cares about you he listens to you he has compation thank you bt

  3. Anonymous says:

    2012 Statistics for this particular ALJ:

    Judge B T Amos 12% Dismissed 48% Approved 40% Denied

    These statistics are available online had those who are critical chosen to thoroughly research. In addition, the Social Security Regulations are online for those who wish to research the criteria for being awarded disability payments under the law. The statistics being cited in previous postings are those thus far for fiscal year 2013, which started October 1, 2012.

  4. Anonymous says:

    Agree with the previous comments. I think they are right on point. Keep in mind that this ALJ is not alone. There are many more like him and in fact many that are worse than him. Despite contrary belief no one believes everyone is disabled and that someone should get something for free. However, something needs to change within the system. There are judges who pay consistently 10-20 percent of their cases. The system needs to change.

  5. Anonymous says:

    An extremely fair Judge who cuts to the chase, knows the law and applies it properly. I would rather be denied by a Judge of this caliber, than to be paid by a liberal, everyone who walks into the hearing office Judge.

  6. Anonymous says:

    This is, without a doubt, the best Judge before whom I have presented cases. His hearings are crisp and to the point. He holds no-nonsense hearings and wants only that you fill in the blanks..he knows the file backwards and forwards and wants you to focus on material not covered or on discrepancies in the record. Word to those interested in what he is looking for: your client need not go in and tell a lie. This is one of his pet peeves. Be up front with him, and don’t annoy him by allowing your client to exaggerate his/her condition. If the medical evidence supports the client’s testimony and meets the letter of the law regarding disability he will issue an award; otherwise, he will not.

  7. Anonymous says:

    I am an attorney who regularly appears before Judge Amos. I am pleased every time my client gets this Judge because I know we will be given a fair hearing. He relies on the testimony to the extent that it is substantiated by the medical evidence of record. He gives great credence to a client who is up front and truthful, not given to histrionics and embellishment. I don’t win every case with this Judge, but I always feel he is fair and well versed in each case.

  8. Anonymous says:

    Will hardly grant any SSI claims, or even SSD claims with expired DLIs. Has HUGE respect for folks with great earnings records. Will probably approve on an AC remand. If you present a fair argument (and you’re not SSI, or expired DLI) he’ll probably pay- and he’ll tell you that at the hearing. If he goes tot he VE and talks about the claimant’s capabilities as opposed to what they are NOT capable of- he’s going to deny.

    Ever since I figured out his pattern, I like him. I just don’t like how I don’t know if I’m going to have him before the hearing!

  9. Anonymous says:

    This Judge has a reputation for being an extremely compassionate but fair Judge. He is known for holding crisp and to the point hearings; it is acknowledged by attorneys and other participants in his hearings that he does not allow “smoke and mirror” type presentations during the hearing process.

  10. susan says:

    Very disappointed in him. My son went before him and was in their 15 minutes. He never asked him one question. My son was denied. My son is 24, neat in appearance, doesn’t abuse his medication (vicotin, xanex, cymbaltra) and has a college degree (college accommodated his disability). I believe this is what he based his decision on. It was never taken into consideration that my son has the body of an 80 year old. He had a double spinal fusion. Has a metal rod from his neck to his butt with about 8 screws 6 inches long in his spine. Doesn’t bend, lift or twist. Lives in constant pain. I could go on and on, like how SS’s dr said he is the worse case they have ever seen. He has now been denied twice. Maybe he should say he is by-polar and he can be approved like half of the other people around here. It’s disgusting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *