M. D Evans , Fort Myers Fl, Florida ODAR Office, Administrative Law Judge

For the 2016 *fiscal year, Judge M D Evans has disposed 1 cases at the Office of Disability Adjudication and Review (ODAR) in Fort Myers Fl, Florida. Out of those 1 dispostions, 0 were dismissed, 0 were approved and 1 were denied. This means that the percentage of dispositions that Judge Evans has approved in Fort Myers Fl for the 2016 fiscal year is 0%. The information below for Judge M D Evans was last updated on 6/11/2019.

Average statistics
Office*Fiscal YearTotal DispositionsTotal DecisionsTotal DenialsTotal AwardsCases
Ft Lauderdale 2010 635 584 211 373 8%59%33%
Fort Myers Fl 2011 519 469 196 273 10%53%38%
Ft Lauderdale 2011 20 20 11 9 0%45%55%
Fort Myers Fl 2012 562 467 256 211 17%38%46%
Ft Lauderdale 2012 3 3 1 2 0%67%33%
Fort Myers Fl 2013 413 349 215 134 15%32%52%
Fort Myers Fl 2014 440 370 280 90 16%20%64%
Ft Lauderdale 2014 6 1 1 0 83%0%17%
Fort Myers Fl 2015 52 52 45 7 0%13%87%
Ft Lauderdale 2015 247 195 145 50 21%20%59%
Fort Myers Fl 2016 1 1 1 0 0%0%100%
Ft Lauderdale 2016 150 114 86 28 24%19%57%
Ft Lauderdale 2017 200 141 88 53 30%26%44%
Ft Lauderdale 2018 87 71 48 23 18%26%55%
*The United States Government fiscal year is from October 1st - September 30th.
M D EvansNo Stats for FY 2020
All ALJs in Fort Myers Fl Office 16% 49% 35%
All ALJs in Florida20%44%36%
All ALJs in the Nation20%42%38%
LATEST COMMENTS      to leave your comment about M D Evans please fill form below comments
Old Rep
Judge: M. D Evans
4/21/2015 12:04:30 PM

Terrible judge. Does not apply the rulings and regulations properly and ignores expert testimony. Relies on DDS consultants and rejects opinion evidence offered by treating doctors and consultants.

Judge: M. D Evans
2/23/2015 4:31:53 PM

I went before Judge Evans today in Melbourne and therefore will not have a decision anytime soon according to my atty, 3-6 months. However I just wanted to say he seemed very nice and cared about my disability. I think the problem with denials is the use of DOT job descriptions. The vocation expert goes by a book that tells job descriptions according to title. What the VE was reading was no where near my job description but...... The judges have to rule by the book, just sayin!

Judge: M. D Evans
11/8/2013 4:16:16 PM

Denied my case with no witnesses and his whole summary said nothing about my medical problems. He stated my angry was not depression related but that I was an alcoholic! I quit drinking 20 years ago in my youth because I was working out and trying to live healthier. Never had a problem with alcohol so this seems like a libel suit. Also the rest of his dribble said nothing about me and he never said a word about my emphysema, left eye blind, no vision right eye, asthma, or anemia. I worked for 30 years and it was not easy but money went into ssd just in case I needed it. We need to get rid of these judges who get paid from this money that was suppose to be for us. How about they give me the money I put in back and we will call it even? Appeals court agreed with me and yesterday it went back to him. He had me see to doctors both paid for by ss and after checking there records, they both see 100 patients a month for ss and have a 99% record of saying people should be denied. At the hearing the judge hired a neor doctor in Texas to testify. I am in Florida. This guy has a 100% denial record. He also has no experience in Psychiatry and optometry yet he testified that I had no depression and could see fine! When my attorney tried to cross examine this guy evans cut him off and refused all his questions! He would not allow my attorney to question him and when he asked to have his testimony thrown out because of Evans denied it. My attorney said he does this to him all the time.

Judge: M. D Evans
10/13/2013 6:11:29 PM

I suffer from uncontrolled epileptic seizures, degenerative disc disease, spinal stenosis, foot drop, severe nerve and muscle damage right leg, nerve damage left leg, and anxiety. Judge Evans denied my disability...I was shocked!..according to his 15 page denial letter, he did not take into consideration the notes from my neurologist, the denial letter stated I have fibromyalgia which I do not have, It was written I have seen doctors in Tampa (um..no... I cannot drive due to seizures)but I live 2 hrs away, and it was shown I was admitted to a facility, when in fact I was not. Judge Evans based his decision upon all of my ER visits due to having grand mal seizures. All the ER doctors were baffled because they are not specialized in seizure disorders and do not realize that 2% of patients on medications still suffer seizures. I have appealed and the appeal was granted. Waiting on another hearing. My conditions have gotten worse. My life has been detrimentally affected due to his lack of investigation and proper research on the evidence that was presented by my attorney. Thumbs down to this judge. He was acting as if he was sitting on the right hand of God that day. Shame on him. I have worked all my life and my medical conditions prevent me from even being able to walk to the mailbox, and seizures several times a week. I feel really bad for the people that will have to go in front of him in the future, especially if you are Caucasian. I was in a prayer group before entering the courtroom. Might I suggest you pray that God will give Judge Evans compassion and pray that God will soften his heart...this denial has absolutely devastated my life, in all ways. Thank you for reading this.

Judge: M. D Evans
2/25/2013 5:00:07 PM

Received my long awaited decision, it wasn't fully favorable but that's because Judge Evans was fair to both sides. I believe his judgement was impressive because what I read in his findings was a judge that not only took my professional doctors words but also heard my personal battle with my disorders. He made the right decision, I told the complete truth an when he pushed for a answer I didn't think what was the right or wrong answer I gave him the honest one. If you go in front of him, tell him 100% what it is that's going on with your disability he listen, but remember he's very sharp : ) he wants to here the way it is an you show him respect an he returns that in his court room. God bless his decision, he tuff but fair. THOMAS

Andrea Hebner
Judge: M. D Evans
9/28/2012 1:02:42 PM

I had mt disability hearing with Judge Evans..I have (epilepst)seizures,fibromyslgia,osteoarthritis,knee problems....I have tried to get many jobs..andnoone will hire me because of my seizure disorder.They say I would be a liability to their company..Judge Evans Denied my disablility..for my seizures I suppose,,I have been throught the Disability system for 5 years now,trying to get this so I can have a normal life and go to the dictors and get the medications that I need...I am very frustrated with our Disability system..and with Mr.Judge Evans for denying my disability,when I truly need it...thank you for listening...

Share your comments about Judge M D Evans

Please Note: This site is privately owned and is not administered by or affiliated with the Social Security Administration.

DO NOT SHARE PERSONAL INFORMATION. These comments are public and are not sent to the SSA, ODAR or the Judge.

The judge might see these comments if he/she views this page, so think before you post. If you need a post removed, please use the "contact us" form on this site. All comments require a valid email address, and your comment will not be made public until you verify your post via email.

Type your comments below:
Rate This Judge:  
Your Name:  
Your Email:  
*required, will not be shown in post

Click here to view complete statistical data for this Judge