Maria Hodges , Dayton, Ohio ODAR Office, Administrative Law Judge

For the 2012 *fiscal year, Judge Maria Hodges has disposed 79 cases at the Office of Disability Adjudication and Review (ODAR) in Dayton, Ohio. Out of those 79 dispostions, 7 were dismissed, 32 were approved and 40 were denied. This means that the percentage of dispositions that Judge Hodges has approved in Dayton for the 2012 fiscal year is 41%. The information below for Judge Maria Hodges was last updated on 6/14/2017.

Average statistics
Office*Fiscal YearTotal DispositionsTotal DecisionsTotal DenialsTotal AwardsCases
Dismissed
Cases
Approved
Cases
Denied
Dayton 2011 4 4 2 2 0%50%50%
Dayton 2012 79 72 40 32 9%41%51%
Huntington 2012 424 380 208 172 10%41%49%
Huntington 2013 697 636 379 257 9%37%54%
Huntington 2014 648 565 320 245 13%38%49%
Huntington 2015 664 570 322 248 14%37%48%
Huntington 2016 579 497 284 213 14%37%49%
Huntington 2017 422 364 189 175 14%41%45%
 Totals:351730881744134412%38%50%
*The United States Government fiscal year is from October 1st - September 30th.
AVERAGE TIME
 DismissedApprovedDenied
Judge Hodges14%41%45%
All ALJs in Dayton Office 21% 40% 39%
All ALJs in Ohio19%42%39%
All ALJs in the Nation21%45%34%
LATEST COMMENTS      to leave your comment about Maria Hodges please fill form below comments
LMA
Judge: Maria Hodges
1/2/2017 1:41:35 AM



I had a hearing before her in July of 2016. Yes, she did ask a lot of questions, very specific ones, and I tried to answer as honestly and truthfully as I could. Yet despite the massive evidence placed before her, she denied me and it has caused disastrous consequences for myself and my husband. My husband is totally disabled, too, and we are living on 475.00 (his SSI) per month now that I cannot work. I have re-filed for help, but am in fear of losing our home before something gives, or before I even get a decision.I have a personal diagnosed history of 2 heart attacks, 3 coronary stents due to coronary artery disease, degenerative disk disease and one past back surgery, arthritis, fibromyalgia, carpal tunnel syndrome, PTSD, generalized anxiety disorder and major bouts of recurrent major depression. In May of this year I fell, resulting in a fractured clavicle and torn tendon of my right rotator cup. Yet after 5 days hospitalization, I returned to work, in great pain, as it was a hot, hard job with heavy lifting, not knowing at the time that my collar bone was fractured. I was summarily dismissed 2 weeks later, and was replaced by a 19-year-old. Of course they did not tell me it was due to my health, but I knew, as hard as I tried, I simply was not able to keep up with the work pace anymore. I explained all of this to her. I also went to Vocational Rehabilitation, but my counselor closed my case, stating she wishes she could help me find placement, but she simply felt that by my medical record, there was no job or training into which she felt she could safely place me. Now, I know that judges are required to follow stringent laws and rules, but I wish I were able to ask Her Honor is she ever truly takes into consideration what kind of havoc her decisions wreak on the lives of those who truly want to be able to work, but who simply cannot do it anymore. I am scared, and I feel there is no place left to turn. I just want to be able to stay in my home, and to pay my bills.

Lawyer representing SSA claimants
Judge: Maria Hodges
6/15/2016 2:14:56 PM



Oh, and to the person who posted 11/20/2012 and said that the vocational expert found you excluded from gainful employment - I think perhaps there's a misunderstanding there as well. Vocational experts typically respond to hypothetical questions about persons with the claimant's age, education and work experience, but with various types of limitations. Normally at least three different hypothetical questions are asked and, yes, the goal is to find a hypothetical individual who most closely matches the claimant's work-related restrictions. The vocational expert never gives testimony about whether or not YOU, the claimant, can or cannot engage in "substantial gainful activity" work. However, it is not uncommon for the expert to identify at least one of the hypothetical people as having no work available to him or her in the national economy. My guess is, the hypothetical individual the ALJ found closest to your situation was NOT identified by the vocational expert as having no work available to him/her, which may have been the basis for your denial.

Lawyer representing SSA claimants
Judge: Maria Hodges
6/14/2016 1:57:18 PM



I've been a member of the bar for over 30 years, and one who has represented claimants in Social Security cases. First of all, to the law student who posted 3/22/14 - by now, you may be practicing law, and no doubt are a bit more seasoned. To speak so disrespectfully about a judge you don't know, and to suggest she should be disbarred, is not appropriate - especially since you apparently are not familiar with the Social Security law's definition of disability. To the rest of you, I am sympathetic, honestly, but I hope that none of you had attorneys or other representatives - if you did, they may not have explained the applicable law to you as carefully as they should have. While your treating physician's opinion is entitled to great weight IF he/she points to objective medical evidence (tests, etc.) and limits his/her opinion to how long you can sit/walk/stand, how much you can lift, and other points of work-related function, other than simply saying you are 'disabled,' it is not entitled to weight if all your doctor says is "my patient is disabled" and there is no indication that he/she has even reviewed Social Security's definition. The law's definition of disability is not the one you find in the dictionary, or what you think of as disability as an average citizen. In reality, the Social Security law is slanted in favor of the claimant, believe it or not. BTW - my experience with Judge Hodges is that she is fair, courteous, and knows the law. I suspect those who are displeased with her here are those who disagreed with her decisions. If so, appeal them - don't complain about her just because you don't agree with her outcome.


Judge: Maria Hodges
3/11/2016 6:58:55 AM



Personally, I don't think she follows the procedure she is supposed to. I have been seeing my doctor every 30 days for 18 years, yet she said in her decision that she placed no credibility in my treating physicians. I was well into a six-figure salary, and I'm not so stupid that I would rather have $2000/mo than $10000/mo. I had a major heart attack in which I had a 95% blockage in the left coronary, and a 90% blockage in my right coronary. The only reason I survived, and this was said by 2 cardiologists, was just so happened that I lived next door to the local ambulance service and stumbled in there before I lost consciousness. If I had waited 10 to 15 minutes for paramedics I would have never survived. Judge Hodges said in her decision that the stenting was successful, and therefore there were no remaining issues with my heart. After showing my cardiologist that, he said "that is the most ludicrous statement I have ever seen!" I still have a 65% blockage that can only be reached by open heart surgery, and all doctors said that my best course of action was to treat the remaining blockage with medication, and to "hang it up". However, she stated that I could do a job as long as I could sit and stand at will, takes breaks as often as I needed one, and as long as my employer placed no pressure to perform at a pace that I could not tolerate. I am over 55, and even the courts VE said I was limited to sedentary work. Even going by the "grid rules" I am considered disabled.

Content
Judge: Maria Hodges
10/23/2015 8:52:04 PM



I personally have sat in front of her to here my case. I found that she was very polite and formal. She knows exactly what she is doing. She was very engaged and interested in hearing my testimony. She asked lots of questions and gave me her undivided attention. I did have a lawyer with me just because I wanted to make sure I was treated fairly after reading horror stories about these hearings. I have not had a decision yet from my hearing but I have no doubt she puts a lot of consideration of the medical facts, testimony, and overall assessment of one's character in her decisions. Regardless Of a favorable decision, if I am given one, I thought she was very professional and fair.


Judge: Maria Hodges
3/22/2014 11:11:48 AM



Her denial rate is approximately 15% higher than the national average....????? Has there ever been any kind of an investigation about a possible motivation for denying claims?


Judge: Maria Hodges
3/22/2014 11:07:05 AM



Wow....I am a law student reading this and it is pretty disheartening. A judge that disregards medical evidence? Isn't that the basis for determining whether or not a disability exists? This so-called "judge" should be disbarred. Personal opinion should not enter into it. A judge is required to make a decision based on the evidence provided.


Judge: Maria Hodges
11/20/2013 3:11:00 PM



To say while sitting on the bench that your physician and therapists reports have no merit is poor judgement. To put more merit on the opinions of so called experts who only is in contact with you for 15 or 20 minutes how this judge renders a decision. I would ask her record be reviewed and something done about her decision making process. While I sit here after working 25 years and in this process for 2 years (and my 2nd denial) I watch my neighbor a drug addicted former nurse breeze through the process and get approved first try!


Judge: Maria Hodges
11/20/2012 5:02:11 PM



Doctor notes and evidence does not matter to her ask me if i had ever seen my dr or did he just write me scripts that is total bs this woman ruined the rest of my life thanks she had her mind made up before i seen her vocational expert said i was excluded from gainful employment but still unfavorabe cause my dr notes and evidence held no weight.


Judge: Maria Hodges
11/20/2012 4:52:13 PM



worst judge ever said my doctors opinion held no weight been going to that doctor for year and a half but the doc the state had me see once matters makes no srnse to me


Judge: Maria Hodges
5/17/2012 7:55:01 AM



wonder if she would even approve her own mother even if she knew her mother was disabled. I kinda doubt it.........just sayin



Share your comments about Judge Maria Hodges

Please Note: This site is privately owned and is not administered by or affiliated with the Social Security Administration.

DO NOT SHARE PERSONAL INFORMATION. These comments are public and are not sent to the SSA, ODAR or the Judge.

The judge might see these comments if he/she views this page, so think before you post. If you need a post removed, please use the "contact us" form on this site. All comments require a valid email address, and your comment will not be made public until you verify your post via email.

Type your comments below:
Rate This Judge:  
Your Name:  
*optional
Your Email:  
*required, will not be shown in post


Click here to view complete statistical data for this Judge