Brian P Kilbane , Charlottesville, Virginia ODAR Office, Administrative Law Judge

For the 2018 *fiscal year, Judge Brian P Kilbane has disposed 18 cases at the Office of Disability Adjudication and Review (ODAR) in Charlottesville, Virginia. Out of those 18 dispostions, 0 were dismissed, 1 were approved and 17 were denied. This means that the percentage of dispositions that Judge Kilbane has approved in Charlottesville for the 2018 fiscal year is 6%. The information below for Judge Brian P Kilbane was last updated on 6/11/2019.

Average statistics
Office*Fiscal YearTotal DispositionsTotal DecisionsTotal DenialsTotal AwardsCases
Charlottesville 2010 760 649 334 315 15%41%44%
Charlottesville 2011 766 641 349 292 16%38%46%
Charlottesville 2012 744 520 321 199 30%27%43%
Charlottesville 2013 608 468 330 138 23%23%54%
Charlottesville 2014 471 362 243 119 23%25%52%
Charlottesville 2015 449 337 241 96 25%21%54%
Charlottesville 2016 388 288 208 80 26%21%54%
Charlottesville 2017 326 232 166 66 29%20%51%
Charlottesville 2018 18 18 17 1 0%6%94%
*The United States Government fiscal year is from October 1st - September 30th.
Brian P KilbaneNo Stats for FY 2020
All ALJs in Charlottesville Office 14% 35% 51%
All ALJs in Virginia20%39%41%
All ALJs in the Nation20%42%38%
LATEST COMMENTS      to leave your comment about Brian P Kilbane please fill form below comments

Judge: Brian P Kilbane
5/1/2017 7:01:52 PM

Update: faith has nothing to do with your decision when it comes to this judge; It's bad when your representative tells you before you go to your hearing that your chances with this judge isn't good, Sad after you have waited 4 years to get a hearing disability said you were disabled as of 2014 but you were trying to get your work credets amended to 2013 because you were disabled then and needed the one work credet to get your monthly check... sad world we live in you work your life and when you are unable to work at 53...ptsd depression 2 knee replacements L5disc bulge fibromyalgia and other health issues... was found disabled by social security but he wouldn't amend one work credet...that was just to much for someone who worked and earned it to ask for....judge kilbane God provided he always has... and I don't have faith in the system but I do have faith in God.... I will appeal....

Betty S Fuller
Judge: Brian P Kilbane
1/20/2017 11:48:02 PM

I don't pre judge anyone. That's a gift my parents taught me as a child. I get nervous reading the reviews but I always have faith. I can only hope that he sees what I feel and my daily struggles through his eyes and if he does that's than that's all I can a honest hearing is on the 31st of this month. Bipolar Anxiety Ptsd 2 knee replacements on my( L ) leg herniated disk in my back due to a bad knee replacement that only last 2 years and had to be taken back out. Broke my leg when they removed it now have plate and screws... constant pain leg hip and back.... walk with a can... I have faith..... Betty Fuller

Judge: Brian P Kilbane
8/31/2015 3:20:29 PM

If you read the appeal cases on his denials you see that sometimes at say step 3 he is found to have properly applied SSA rules in a case and the plaintiff is wrong, so from this you gather he knows how to apply SSA rules. But in other cases say at step 3 it is found that he has not properly applied SSA rules according to the appeals council. Why does he properly apply SSA rules in some cases but not in others? He obviously knows how to because the appeals process says he has done it properly. Why does he properly apply SSA rules in some cases but not others? Is he allowed to pick and choose?

Judge: Brian P Kilbane
8/31/2015 1:00:15 PM

Outliers are investigated by SSA at 25%. He is just above outlier status at 28% approvals. He also has enough cases overturned on appeal to make his credibility questionable in my opinion.

Judge: Brian P Kilbane
1/7/2013 1:46:21 PM

i have had a few hearings with him and he's not as bad as the other guy says but he doesnt say much. just makes his decisions. i dont mind the fact he doesnt say much but he is pretty conservative. there are worse ones for sure

sword of dam
Judge: Brian P Kilbane
12/23/2012 7:06:08 AM

he is without question the most insulting least engaged judge there is anywhere. i have had dozens of cases with him and he almost always ASKS NO QUESTIONS AND BARELY LOOKS UP at the claimant. this is on top of his ultra conservative views (remember this is a government employee doing this who has everything paid for by uncle sam). I have had about 30 hearing with this poor excuse for not only a (chief?)judge but a human being. i have had at least 2 heatings where he completely-i mean totally.. distorted the evidence and ignored long repeated periods of mental confinement to put forth a hypothetical that denied a seriously mentally ill client of mine. another case 55 yr old 35 yr worker at one plant with fusions on neck back and multiple repetitive surgeries for running jackhammer for years. on top of this, he has a breakdown when he lost his teenage son. the file complete with attempts to place him and do the best he could. not one question from this jerk. not one. summary denial..astonishing..... i dont know ** he got to be chief judge but his propensity not not only to deny every possible case but to distort the evidence to try to erase facts from the record makes this guy the jerk of all jerks. one day when he lays down he will have to face how he treated everyone in his life..and just on my cases alone, this guy will need all the luck he can get. this is but an example of many cases i have had with him. if you want to know whats wrong with this country, look at his face. there is absolutely no excuse for this guy. i have been doing this practice for over 20 yrs...if you want to be tight, ok..but dont distort the record...i can honestly say this about only one judge in my 25+ yr career but its true: I have no respect for this guy as a human being, nor do i wish to live on the same street as this jerk.

Share your comments about Judge Brian P Kilbane

Please Note: This site is privately owned and is not administered by or affiliated with the Social Security Administration.

DO NOT SHARE PERSONAL INFORMATION. These comments are public and are not sent to the SSA, ODAR or the Judge.

The judge might see these comments if he/she views this page, so think before you post. If you need a post removed, please use the "contact us" form on this site. All comments require a valid email address, and your comment will not be made public until you verify your post via email.

Type your comments below:
Rate This Judge:  
Your Name:  
Your Email:  
*required, will not be shown in post

Click here to view complete statistical data for this Judge